Thursday, March 18, 2010

Book Recommendations for 3rd & 4th Grade Boys

A teacher friend of mine prompted this blog post. Actually, she asked me for this list over a year ago, and she knows how very, truly sorry I am that it's taken me this long to get it for her. Once I had done so, though, I thought I might share it with the world.

The followi
ng list is a brief overview of some books that are currently in-print that I think would suit the tastes of boys who are in 3rd or 4th grade, or who are reading at a 3rd or 4th grade level. Having never been a 3rd or 4th grade boy, my opinion comes from having a father, an older brother, and many boy customers, all of whom I observe and talk with about books. The general trend runs toward sports, "funny" books, and action/adventure. I'm also throwing some part-graphic novel titles on here, just for fun.

The original series I recommended at the teacher's request was the Dan Gutman series, Baseball Card Adventures (HarperCollins). These stories featured a boy who upon touching a baseball card, would be transported back in time to meet, say, Mickey Mantle or Shoeless Joe.

Continuing on the sports theme, I would also recommend a series by Loren Long and Phil Bildner, originally known as Barnstormers when it was a hardcover-only series, now known as Sluggers in hardcover/paperback (Simon & Schuster). This has a similar feel to the Dan Gutman series, in that it combines baseball and magic, but aren't high-fantasy (no goblins, trolls, etc.). There are six in the series so far. My favorite aspect of this series is that a lot of baseball terminology and slang are used right in the prose, and then defined in the margins of the page. You get to read a great baseball adventure story and learn baseball vocab - what could be better than that?

One last sports series, that's not baseball specific is the Comeback Kids series by Mike Lupica (Penguin). Each book features a boy playing a different sport; so, for instance, one plays basketball, one football, one baseball, etc.

On to non-sports recommendations:

Doctor Proctor's Fart Powder by Jo Nesbo, illustrated by Mike Lowery (9781416979722, $14.99, Simon & Schuster). The word "fart" is in the title. Need I say more?

The Indian in the Cupboard (series) by Lynne Reid Banks (Random House). An oldie but a goodie, though being sensitive to the portrayal of Native Americans in literature, I have to say this series is typically lacking in its cultural sensitivity and accurate tribal-specific information. That said, I read this series as a kid and it's what, in part, influenced me in becoming a Native American studies major in college. So, you never know.

Never underestimate the power of the
Choose Your Own Adventure novel, mostly written by R.A. Montgomery, though other writers fill in the series (Chooseco). These don't need to be read in order. They have started publishing some CYOAs at the beginning chapter book level for 1st and 2nd graders, too.

The Jon Scieszka recommendation section of this post:

Knucklehead by Jon Scieszka (9780670011384, $12.99, Penguin). The subtitle is Tall Tales and Mostly True Stories of Growing Up Scieszka. These tales feature the outlandish (mostly true) events that occur when you grow up as one of six brothers. Pictures of Jon Scieszka and his family are sprinkled throughout the book. Some parents have been sensitive to the cover - it was designed specifically that way to reflect the covers of comic books that Scieszka read as a child that age, not as a political statement of today.

Noisy Outlaws, Unfriendly Blobs, and Some Other Things...
(...that aren't as scary, maybe, depending on how you feel about lost lands, stray cellphones, creatures form the sky, parents who disappear in Peru, a man named Lars Farf, and one other story we couldn't quite finish, so maybe you could help us out)

by Nick Hornby, Neil Gaiman, Jon Scieszka, Jonathan Safran Foer, etc. (9780385737470, $12.99, Random House). Besides winning best title of the decade, this book is a great introduction to some fantastic authors. Basically these are all short stories, a few pages long, mostly sci-fi or fantasy-related. A good introduction to this genre and these writers for kids at the Middle Grade reading level.

A similar book for those reading at the higher end of Middle Grade, say 10-14 years old, try Guys Write for Guys Read, edited by Jon Scieszka (9780670011445, $11.99, Penguin). This is the same type of book where all the stories are a few pages long, only not only sci-fi/fantasy-based tales. In this compilation, all the contributing writers are guys, writing for a guy audience.

Part graphic novel, part regular novel recommendations:

Frankie Pickle and the Closet of Doom & Frankie Pickle and the Pine Run 3000 (series starring Frankie Pickle) by Eric Wight (Simon & Schuster). This series is a little easier reading level for those reluctant readers, more of a 2nd to 3rd grade level. The "every day" scenes are in prose; it's when Frankie's imagination takes over that the graphic novel element comes to life.

Dragonbreath (series) by Ursula Vernon (Penguin). A relatively new series starring a little dragon as the main character, but in the role of a boy; also featuring a foreign exchange student (a salamander) and ninja frogs.

The Fog Mound (trilogy) by Susan Schade and Jon Buller (Simon & Schuster). Recommended by my Simon & Schuster book rep, this series is about a chipmunk named Thelonious who is given the chance to find out if the old stories are true - if people rather than animals once ruled the Earth, and if they did, what happened to the humans?

Now that you've heard my two cents, does the peanut gallery have any favorites they'd like to add?



Charlotte said...

Great list! I've tried a number of them on my own 4th grader, and I'll look for the others.

LNSabadosa said...

How about "Book Recommendations for 3rd and 4th Graders" - period? Or adventure stories or mysteries or whatever. Is there something that makes these books enjoyable only to boys? I must have missed that memo because I read Indian in the Cupboard when I was in 2nd grade and LOVED it. And no y-chromosome here. Let's knock off that boy book/girl book business and let kids read what they want without setting up any silly guidelines that make them feel like they're making the wrong choice if they pick something that some arbitrary person deems appropriate for the other sex. The very fact that there is a teacher out there dividing the world into boys books/girl books is very troubling.

Rebecca Fabian said...

Thanks to everyone for their comments!

To LNSabadosa: You've made a valid point about not gendering books and other reading material toward either boys or girls. Yet, I think some facts need to be faced. While I can't quote statistics, in my years working with children's literature, there has been national recognition that boys tend to read less than girls. National foundations such as Guys Read ( (begun by the first Library of Congress National Ambassador of Young People's Literature, Jon Scieszka) have been formed to encourage boys to read.
Also, boys and girls do tend to trend toward books that are marketed specifically for them. Pink covers for "girl" books, "boy" books often are about sports. These generalities need to be recognized and then moved beyond, and many readers, teachers, parents, and booksellers do just that. I, too, loved Indian in the Cupboard, and mentioned that in my post.
In defense of the teacher who asked me for this list, her boy readers were READING SO MUCH that she was looking to find other books that they would like. THAT is where this list was born, and I applaud her for using her community resources (this local bookstore) as a place where she could receive those recommendations. I apologize if my post made it seem otherwise.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the list. I have been looking for something of interest to my grand son in order to get him to read more without groaning, "do I hafta?" and this list certainly fits the bill. I never had any trouble with getting the girls to read, but my grand son's interest is VASTLY different than his sisters' and so I had to find a different way to encourage him. This one works!

kienieb1 said...

It seems that LNSabadosa just wants something to complain about. I have a boy who is not fond of reading. It's nice to see a list that will help whittle the research time so I can concentrate on the more important things like teaching my son.